Dimi's LinkedIn field guide · exam 2 Oct
Home › Budget & bidding

Budget & bidding — how the auction works

08 / 22 Day 4 ~25 min read
In one sentence

It is an auction: highest bid × relevance score wins and pays just enough to beat the runner-up. Better creative buys cheaper media.

$10per day minimum$100lifetime minimum+50%a day can overspend€1–2per day per 1,000 members
Three advertisers want the same member's feed slot score = bid × relevance (predicted engagement, 0–1). Highest score wins and pays just enough to beat the runner-up. Advertiser Abids €12×relevance 0.55= 6.6 loud but dull ad Advertiser Bbids €8×relevance 1.00= 8.0 WINS great creative Advertiser Cbids €10×relevance 0.70= 7.0 runner-up
B pays roughly €7.01 — just above C's score divided by B's relevance — not the €8 it bid. Better creative = cheaper media. Say this in every creative review.

The auction in one line

Winner = highest (bid × relevance score), and pays just enough to beat the runner-up (second-price logic). Relevance score = predicted engagement/CTR of the ad for that member. Better creative lowers the price.

StrategyWhat it doesWhen
Maximum delivery (automated)Spends full budget at whatever price winsDefault; large audiences, deadline campaigns, no time to manage
Cost capTargets an average cost per key result; can under-deliverEfficiency with a known target CPC/CPL
Manual biddingYou set the max bid per click/impression/view/sendSmall audiences, experienced buyers; start under the suggested range, +10% steps
Qualified Leads Optimisation (QLO)Send MQL/SQL signals back via CAPI; delivery skews to similar members≥ ~50 qualified events / month
Conversion Value Optimisation (CVO)Optimises toward higher-value conversionsValue passed via CAPI

How the second-price auction settles

LinkedIn runs a modified second-price auction: the ranking uses bid × relevance, and the winner pays the lowest bid that would still have won, not the bid it entered. Every time a member opens the feed, this happens in milliseconds:

  1. Eligibility. Every ad set whose targeting matches the member, that still has budget and that pacing allows to bid right now, enters.
  2. Prediction. LinkedIn predicts how likely this member is to engage with each ad: the relevance score.
  3. Floor check. Bids below the floor for this audience and placement are dropped.
  4. Ranking. Score = bid × relevance. Highest score wins the slot.
  5. Price. Winner pays runner-up's score ÷ winner's relevance + €0.01. Never more than the bid, never less than the floor.
  6. Billing. You are charged in the ad set's unit: per impression, click, view or send.
AdvertiserBidRelevanceScoreRankPays
B — great creative€81.008.01st7.0 ÷ 1.00 + 0.01 = €7.01
C€100.707.02ndnothing — lost
A — dull creative€120.556.63rdnothing — lost
Why this matters for the client: in a second-price auction, bidding your real maximum is safe. You only pay what the competition forces you to pay. The lever that actually lowers the price is relevance: when relevance doubles, the same runner-up costs you half as much. Schematic: behind the scenes LinkedIn converts CPC and CPM bids into a common value per impression, but the logic is the same.

Bid floors and pacing

Floors — the reserve price

  • Every audience and placement has a floor (minimum bid). With manual bidding, Campaign Manager shows it and will not save a bid below it.
  • If you are the only bidder above the floor, you pay the floor, not your bid.
  • The floor rises with demand: senior titles, small high-value audiences, IT, finance and HR in DACH, quarter-ends and Q4.
  • Suggested bid range ≠ floor. It is a forecast of what competing advertisers pay for this audience. The site's rule still holds: start under it, then raise in +10% steps.
  • Text ads have a fixed minimum bid of $2 CPC or $2 CPM.

Pacing — how the money is spread

  • LinkedIn paces automatically. A daily budget is spread across the hours when your audience is active, so €300 does not disappear at 09:00. A lifetime budget is spread across the flight.
  • With Maximum delivery, pacing and the bid are automatic: the system bids whatever it needs to use the budget.
  • With manual bids or a cost cap, pacing tries to spend but the win rate limits it. If you lose most auctions, you see it as underspend. The money is not saved; the plan simply does not happen.
  • A total budget and schedule on the Campaign (formerly Campaign Group) caps all its ad sets together. Use it when the IO is a fixed amount.
  • Rule of thumb, not a LinkedIn rule: change budgets and bids in 20–30% steps, then wait 2–3 days before judging. Big jumps reset what automated bidding has learned.

Manual vs maximum delivery vs target cost vs cost cap

Every strategy trades delivery for cost control Left: LinkedIn spends the budget at whatever price the market asks. Right: you control the price, not the spend. Maximum deliveryTarget costCost capManual bid spends it allprice floats average near targetcan run above it average ≤ capmay underspend your max per unityou manage it daily ← delivery first cost control first →
Target cost is the older, softer version of cost cap. You will still see it on old ad sets and in exam questions. New ad sets offer Cost cap.
StrategyYou setLinkedIn doesSpends full budget?Main riskUse when
Maximum deliveryBudget onlyBids automatically to get the most results for the budgetYes, almost alwaysCost per result drifts up on small or competitive audiencesNew account, first 2–3 weeks to learn the market price, deadline campaigns, awareness
Target cost (legacy)A target average cost per resultKeeps the average near the target; single results above or belowUsuallyAverage can settle above the targetOld ad sets; know it for the exam
Cost capA ceiling on the average cost per key resultMaximises results while keeping the average at or below the capOnly if the cap is at or above marketUnderdeliveryYou know the CPL/CPA you can afford and have history to set it
Manual biddingMax bid per click, impression, view or sendEnters auctions at up to your bid; you still pay second priceOnly if the bid wins enough auctionsToo low = no spend; too high = overpaying on small audiencesSmall or ABM audiences, experienced buyers, when Max delivery overpays

A sequence that works in most accounts: launch on Maximum delivery → after 2–3 weeks read the real cost per result → switch to a cost cap 10–20% above that number, or to a manual bid just under the average CPC/CPM paid → tighten in small steps.

Cost cap behaviour

  • The cap applies to the average cost per result over the ad set's life, not to each result. Single leads can cost more than the cap.
  • You are still billed per impression or click. The cap is what the system steers the average cost per result (lead, conversion, click) towards.
  • A cap below what the market costs does not overspend, it underspends. Delivery slows until the auction gives results at that price, or never does.
  • The first days are often above the cap while the system learns. Judge after 7 days, not 2.
  • Raising the cap by 10–20% opens more auctions. Improving creative (relevance) wins more of them at the same cap. That is the cheaper fix.
  • A cap needs budget room. Rule of thumb: a daily budget of at least 3–5× the cap, or the system sees too few results to steer.
  • Do not stack a tight cap on a tiny audience with Audience Expansion off. That is the classic €0-spend combination.

Pricing units

CPMcost per 1,000 impressions — Brand awareness, reach CPCcost per click — Website visits, Engagement, Lead gen CPVcost per video view (2 s, ≥50% in view) CPScost per send — Sponsored Messaging (paid when delivered, not opened) CPL / CPAcost per lead / per action — outcomes you report, not bid units (except via cost cap)

Budgets, pacing, frequency

  • Minimum $10/day per ad set, $100 lifetime (EUR equivalents shown in account currency).
  • Daily budget can be exceeded by up to 50% on a given day; LinkedIn averages over the calendar week — say this before finance asks.
  • Rule of thumb: €1–2 / day per 1,000 members in a cold audience.
  • Lifetime budgets pace across the schedule; daily + lifetime combined gives a hard cap.
  • Sponsored Messaging has strict per-member frequency caps, so a member rarely sees your message twice in a short period.
  • Ad review takes up to 24 h; rejections: superlatives ("No. 1", "guaranteed"), before/after images, landing page ≠ ad.
  • Run 3–5 ads per ad set; refresh creative every 2 weeks on audiences < 10k, monthly > 100k.
Why an ad set does not spend — checklist in order
  1. Bid below the floor for the audience
  2. Ad in review or rejected
  3. Campaign (group) paused or schedule ended
  4. Audience too small for the format
  5. Daily budget below the bid
  6. Billing failed
  7. Conversion-optimised ad set with no conversion volume
  8. Frequency exhausted — new creative resets it

Daily vs lifetime budgets

Daily budgetLifetime budgetDaily + lifetime together
What it limitsAverage spend per day (+50% on a busy day)Total spend over the flightBoth: steady pacing with a hard total
End dateOptional; runs until pausedRequiredRequired
PacingEven day by dayLinkedIn shifts spend to days with more opportunityLifetime pacing, but never above the daily limit
Best forAlways-on programmes, monthly IOs, testsFixed-amount flights: events, launches, trade fairsFinance-sensitive clients: "never more than X, never more than Y a day"
Watch outA +50% day surprises finance; say it upfrontEditing it mid-flight re-paces the rest; spend can bunch near the endA daily limit that is too low means the lifetime total is never reached

Minimum spend rules

RuleValueWhat it means in practice
Daily budget per ad set$10 (account-currency equivalent)Floor to go live, not a useful budget; see the €1–2/day per 1,000 members rule
Lifetime budget per ad set$100A lifetime budget also needs an end date
Daily overspendup to +50% on a given dayAveraged over the calendar week, so the plan holds
Manual bid≥ the floor shown in Campaign ManagerFloors differ by audience, format and placement
Text adsminimum bid $2 CPC or $2 CPMThe cheapest format to enter, and the weakest placement
Audience300 matched members to serve; 1,000+ stableBelow that, no amount of budget delivers
Conversion-optimised bidding~50 conversions / month; QLO ~50 qualified eventsNeeded monthly budget ≈ 50 × expected CPA
Useful test≈ €4k / month mediaLess than that and the full-funnel read is noise
Currencyset once per ad accountWrong currency = new ad account

Why a campaign underdelivers

Underdelivery is a price signal: the market is telling you the bid, the cap or the creative is below what this audience costs. Go through the checklist above for "no spend at all". Use this table when it spends some, but not enough:

SymptomLikely causeFix
€0 from day oneBid below floor, ad in review or rejected, billing, schedule not startedCheck the Status and Delivery columns; move the bid up to the floor
Spends 20–60% every dayManual bid or cost cap below market+10% bid steps, or raise the cap 10–20%, or improve creative
Spent well, then fadesFrequency > 5, CTR falling, so relevance and win rate fall tooNew creative, or widen the audience; lower the daily budget on small audiences
Spends only on some daysSmall audience; competition spikes (quarter-end, Q4, trade fairs)Widen targeting or lengthen the flight; accept that a lifetime budget will bunch
Conversion ad set barely spendsToo few conversions for the model to learnOptimise for a higher-funnel event, or merge ad sets to pool volume
Penetration < 30% after a monthBid too low for this audienceRaise the bid or switch to Maximum delivery for two weeks to read the price
Much less than forecastLayered targeting plus Audience Expansion and Audience Network off shrank the reachable poolCheck the forecast after every targeting change; keep feed audiences above 50k where you can
Mid-December: DACH budgets freeze and B2B feeds go quiet. Plan Q4 spend into October–November, not into the last two weeks of the year.

Worked examples

1 · Settling an auction, and what bad creative costs

Same three advertisers as the diagram. B wins with 8.0 and pays 7.0 ÷ 1.00 + 0.01 = €7.01.

Now B's creative gets tired and relevance drops to 0.80: score 8 × 0.80 = 6.4. That is below C (7.0) and A (6.6), so B is third and loses. C now wins and pays A's score ÷ C's relevance = 6.6 ÷ 0.70 + 0.01 = €9.44, still under its €10 bid.

Add a floor of €7.50 per click for this audience. If B still had relevance 1.00, it would pay max(€7.01, €7.50) = €7.50.

Lesson: the same €8 bid went from a €7.01 click to no click at all. Only the creative changed.

2 · Sizing a budget from the audience

Audience: 70,000 IT managers in DACH at 200–1,000-employee companies. Rule: €1–2 per day per 1,000 members → €70–140 / day.

  1. Pick €100/day → ≈ €3,040 / month (30.4 days).
  2. At a €50 CPM: 100 ÷ 50 × 1,000 = 2,000 impressions / day → ≈ 60,800 / month.
  3. If 50% of the audience is reached (35,000 members), frequency = 60,800 ÷ 35,000 ≈ 1.7 per month. That is too thin for recall, so either narrow to the best 35k or go to €140/day.
3 · A manual bid ladder

Suggested CPC range €11–16, daily budget €100. Start under the range at €9.50.

DayBidSpend of €100Avg CPCAction
1–3€9.50€22€9.30Winning too little → +10%
4–6€10.45€61€9.85Improving → hold
7–9€10.45€96€10.10Full spend → lock

The same audience on Maximum delivery had averaged €13.40. Manual saves (13.40 − 10.10) ÷ 13.40 ≈ 25% per click, in line with the study finding that bidding low cuts cost per result by about a third.

4 · A cost cap that underdelivers, and three fixes

Client can afford a €160 CPL. Cost cap €160, daily budget €250 (€1,750 / week), audience 25k.

Week 1: spent €480 (27%), 3 leads, CPL €160. The cap holds, but the market price for this audience is nearer €200.

  1. Raise the cap 15% to €185: more auctions open; CPL rises toward the cap.
  2. Widen the audience 25k → 60k: more cheap auctions to win at €160.
  3. Better creative, e.g. a document ad (≈42% lower CPL): relevance rises, so the same cap wins more.

Week 3, with the document ad and the cap unchanged: spent €1,520, 10 leads, CPL €152. The creative fixed the delivery, not the money.

5 · Daily vs lifetime for a 21-day trade-fair push

Budget €6,300 over 21 days; the fair is at the end of week 3.

  • Daily €300: steady; any day may spend up to €450, but the week averages €2,100. Total ≈ €6,300.
  • Lifetime €6,300 + end date: LinkedIn spreads it, e.g. €200 on weekends and €380 midweek, and finishes on budget.
  • You want the weight in the final week: lifetime pacing will not do that. Use a daily budget and change it: €200 → €200 → €500 per day = 1,400 + 1,400 + 3,500 = €6,300.
6 · Can this budget feed automated conversion bidding?

Website conversions (demo requests), expected CPA ≈ €280. Needs ~50 conversions a month → 50 × 280 = €14,000 / month.

Client budget €5,000 → 5,000 ÷ 280 ≈ 18 conversions, too thin to learn. Options: optimise for a Lead Gen Form content lead (≈ €150 → 33 / month), pool ad sets into one, or run Website visits plus retargeting and let the conversions come from the retargeting pool.

7 · Why a small ABM ad set stalls in week 2

Matched audience 12,000, daily €200, CPM €70 → 200 ÷ 70 × 1,000 ≈ 2,857 impressions / day → 40,000 in two weeks.

Penetration 55% = 6,600 members reached → frequency 40,000 ÷ 6,600 ≈ 6.1 in two weeks. That is above 5, so CTR falls, relevance falls, the price rises and spend stalls.

Fix: halve the daily budget to €100, or add 3 new ads, or add adjacent job functions to the list.

Remember
  • Maximum delivery spends everything; Cost cap targets an average cost; Manual sets your own bid.
  • CPM for awareness, CPC for clicks and leads, CPV for video, CPS for messaging.
  • Daily budget is averaged over the calendar week — say it before finance asks.
  • The winner pays the runner-up's score ÷ its own relevance + €0.01. Never more than the bid, never less than the floor.
  • Cost cap caps the average. A cap below market does not overspend, it underspends.
  • Underdelivery = bid, cap or creative below market. Automated conversion bidding needs ≈ 50 × CPA a month.
← PrevNext →